Archive Page Design
Click here to go to Balletco's new home page and site navigation

About the Change
HomeMagazineListingsUpdateLinksContexts





Australian Ballet with Bangarra Dance Theatre

‘Les Presages’, ‘Rites’

October 2008
London, Sadler's Wells

by Natasha Rogai



© John Ross

AB 'Les Presages' reviews

'Les Presages' reviews

AB 'Rites' reviews

'Rites' reviews

Thaiday in reviews

recent Australian Ballet reviews

recent Bangarra reviews

more Natasha Rogai reviews

Discuss this review
(Open for at least 6 months)

Gallery of Photographs




As posted on our Postings pages...

I caught the programme on Friday night and came away rather disappointed. I had never seen Les Presages before and found it hard to judge on the basis of this performance. Clearly the work is of its time and looks a little old-fashioned, but the use of groupings is effective and there are some genuinely original ideas, especially in the use of arms. The problem to me is that this is a symphonic ballet which stands or falls by the musicality of the choreography and that can only be conveyed by dancers who themselves are innately musical. Also, it was created by a Russian choreographer, with Russian dancers, to great Russian music – which means it cries out for the Russian flow of movement in the whole body and the arms are as important as the legs. My personal gripe about many Australian ballet dancers (and I hasten to say there are some very honourable exceptions to this!) is that they dance well from the waist down but tend to be stiff and inexpressive in the upper body, which in itself leads to a lack of musicality. This was all too evident in the performance I saw. The dancers were competent technically, but it felt as if they were simply executing the steps rather than responding to or expressing the music. Of the soloists, I felt Ramos and Rawlins were seriously miscast and Reiko Hombo in the third movement fared best. She is a pleasingly light and graceful dancer and unafflicted by Australian Arm Disease, but even she did not make me feel the connection between the choreography and the music. Perhaps Massine just wasn’t a musical choreographer – perhaps it’s just me! - but I will reserve judgment until I have seen the work done by another company. The Bolshoi have been doing Massine and I suspect that they would be much better equipped to do justice to it.

 


Les Presages
© John Ross


According to the chap sitting next to me I was unlucky, as the first cast had been much better. Even if so, a company of this standing should be able to field a better second (or even third) cast than this, especially on an international tour. Nor did I care for Toer Van Schyk’s new designs – given that they kept the period feel rather than doing something completely new it would have been better to use the originals.

 


Patrick Thaiday in Rites
© John Ross


The company looked more at home in Rites, their collaboration with Bangarra Dance Theatre, where I enjoyed the athleticism and commitment of their dancing. The piece is not the best treatment I’ve seen of Rite of Spring – I thought much of the choreography for the individual passages was good, but breaking the piece into separate sections rather than following the original story (or replacing it with another one) works against the music, which is so organic and builds to such a strong climax. Curiously, given that the work is supposed to draw on aboriginal dance traditions, I felt some of the choreography was almost too balletic – the best versions of Rite of Spring, from Nijinsky’s original onwards, are resolutely un-balletic. I was also sorry there was so little use of Bangarra’s dancers – the only one with a substantial role, Patrick Thaiday, was tremendous.


{top} Home Magazine Listings Update Links Contexts
...nov08/nr_rev_australian_ballet_with_bangarra_dance_theatre_1008.htm revised: 19 October 2008
Bruce Marriott email, © all rights reserved, all wrongs denied. credits
written by Natasha Rogai © email design by RED56