Archive Page Design
Click here to go to Balletco's new home page and site navigation

About the Change
HomeMagazineListingsUpdateLinksContexts





Royal Ballet

‘Manon’

November 2008
London, Covent Garden

by Carmela



© John Ross

RB 'Manon' reviews

'Manon' reviews

Marquez in reviews

Putrov in reviews

recent RB reviews

more Carmela reviews

Discuss this review
(Open for at least 6 months)

Gallery of Photographs




As posted on our Postings pages...

I agree very much with what you say - I too was a bit cautious too post, especially as I am not a huge fan of either dancer and I was afraid that maybe my judgement had been colored by that fact. But I was interested to see Marquez particularly in this role, since the reviews of her Juliet were so positive. On their own, they were both technically well in command of the roles. It may be the fact that they had not had adequate rehearsal time which contributed to the technical problems in the pdds, but for me also the problem was that they were not convicing in their portrayal because they didn't seem convinced themselves. For example, one key moment is the point where Manon is presented with the fur coat and the jewels... Here she must show something really clearly so that we understand how she was swayed, either that she is just fickle and cares more about jewels than love, or that she is impressionable. With Roberta you just saw something like, oh now she has some jewels, and because of that, it just didn't hold together - the story just didn't come to life.

Regarding the pdds... I have to say that I was surprised, that considering Roberta and Ivan are such a regular partnership, they didn't seem very comfortable with each other. To be honest, I understand that they probably got placed together because of their heights, but I don't really think this partnership works. It doesn't seem to inspire either of them to new levels: for instance, Roberta really does seem to dance much better with Thiago and Johan. Ivan seemed quite tired at the end, which didn't help matters.

 


Ivan Putrov - Des Grieux and Roberta Marquez in Manon
© John Ross


Helen Crawford did pretty well with the Mistress, obviously she is cast a little out of her comfort zone (in terms of her rank in the Company and previous roles at this level) but it was a good performance. I think she would have been helped to go to an even higher level if the cast around her had been stronger. I guess it must be quite a struggle to fill this role, since Morera who usually dances it is performing alot in the title role, Sarah Lamb is injured, and it seems that Marianela isn't taking the role this time round (I haven't seen the programme so I don't know if she was listed) either because of her very busy schedule or her injury.

Maloney was a little anonymous as Lescaut, but Gary Avis was a fantastic GM. There was some great dancing in the smaller roles, but altogether, the performance never really took off.


{top} Home Magazine Listings Update Links Contexts
...dec08/ca_rev_rb_1108.htm revised: 9 November 2008
Bruce Marriott email, © all rights reserved, all wrongs denied. credits
written by Carmela © email design by RED56