HomeMagazineListingsUpdateLinksContexts

 


 Ballet.co Postings Pages

 Some Special Threads:
  TodaysLinks - worldwide daily dance links
  UKWhatsOnWhere - See what's on near you and post
      details of performances in the News forum
  KirovTalk talk about the Kirov
  BolshoiTalk talk about the Bolshoi
  NBTTalk about Northern Ballet Theatre
  ENBTalk about English National Ballet
  BRBTalk about Birmingham Royal Ballet
  Ballet.co GetTogethers - meetings and drinks...
  Ballet.co BookClub - discerning reading shared!


Ballet.co Postings

Subject: "ROH2 Pinocchio Discussion (and pictures)" Archived thread - Read only
 
  Previous Topic | Next Topic
Printer-friendly copy     Email this topic to a friend    
Conferences What's Happening Topic #5373
Reading Topic #5373
Bruceadmin

14-12-05, 12:29 PM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail Bruce Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
"ROH2 Pinocchio Discussion (and pictures)"
 
  
John Ross was at the Linbury photoshoot yesterday...



Pinocchio - Matthew Hart with Geppetto - Luke Haydon




Will Kemp as Stromboli


ROH2 - Pinocchio - Linbury - Dec 2005
Ballet.co Gallery Area
all images © John Ross

Pinocchio Opens on Friday - more details here:
http://www.ballet.co.uk/dcforum/news/2996.html

Thoughts, views and reviews in this thread please...


  Printer-friendly page | Top

  Subject     Author     Message Date     ID  
  Review - 16 December 2005 Premiere Bruceadmin 17-12-05 1
     RE: Review - 16 December 2005 Premiere alison 17-12-05 2
         RE: Review - 16 December 2005 Premiere JohnM 17-12-05 3
             Review - 17 December 2005 matinee Mandy 18-12-05 4
                 Leora Kent's Review - 17 December 2005 matinee Mandy 21-12-05 5
                     RE: Leora Kent's Review - 17 December 2005 matinee JohnM 21-12-05 6
                         Leora Kent's Review - 17 December 2005 matinee Mandy 21-12-05 7
                             Thurs 29th performance and workshop Mandy 29-12-05 8
                                 Pinocchio JMcN 30-12-05 9
                                     RE: Pinocchio Ann Welsh 30-12-05 10
                                     RE: Pinocchio Tony Newcombe 30-12-05 11
                                     RE: Pinocchio AnnWilliams 30-12-05 12
                                     RE: Pinocchio Mandy 30-12-05 13
                                     RE: Pinocchio Ann Welsh 30-12-05 14
                                     RE: Pinocchio Robert 03-01-06 15
                                     RE: Pinocchio JohnM 03-01-06 16
                                     RE: Pinocchio Robert 04-01-06 17
                                     RE: Pinocchio Sim 04-01-06 18

Conferences | Topics | Previous Topic | Next Topic
Bruceadmin

17-12-05, 10:11 AM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail Bruce Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
1. "Review - 16 December 2005 Premiere"
In response to message #0
 
   LAST EDITED ON 17-12-05 AT 05:02 PM (GMT)
 

Pinocchio
ROH2- Linbury
16 Decmeber 2005

From childhood all I can remember of Pinocchio is his lying and his nose getting longer. It's etched in my memory and always came to mind whenever I felt like telling a porky pie(*): "Should I risk it, or will my nose give me away!". I don't remember anything else of the story and Will Tuckett's new production came as a massive and rather pleasant surprise.

As Geppetto, Pinocchio's father might put it, 'Pinocchio is most wonder and brilliantissimo excersion'. It's not a dance show, more a musical where its Italian roots often ring through in vague and daft English - think Manuel and Fawlty Towers. But the plot is also breathtaking in its scope: how could I not remember the storm and shipwreck, the meeting in the belly of a shark, the evil puppeteer Stromboli's glue factory, his sly assistants, the Fox and the Cat and his eventual stabbing to death by the hero? Dark in places it may be, but it's all topped off with a happy ending masterminded by a Blue Fairy who always seems to scooter on (literally) when things have got particularly grim.

The designers have done a great job - the costumes are full of rich and inventive detail, all with a stylised 19th century theatrical look. The sets are also 19th century in their working - they rely on physically being manhandled to achieve their big and wonderous effects - but they work well. It's all the opposite of cgi films and slick cleverness, though I have to say that Pinocchio's growing nose is rather brilliant and very much 21st century. This is earthy traditional theatre with the show actually starting with the dance actors out in the audience and we are included us at other times too (don't worry, nothing embarrassing).

The music is jaunty and simple, courtesy of a 6-piece orchestra performing on stage, with much of it led by an accordion or clarinet. Charmingly unsophisticated, as is the singing of much of the cast. Sometimes however we couldn't always make out Phil Porter's words/lyrics and in a couple of places the plot seemed slow - the odd adjustment and tweak will happen I'm sure.

ROH2 has a terrific bunch of freelance dancers associated with it and it was good to see so many 'old friends' on stage - Matthew Hart, Luke Heydon, Cathy Marston, Charlotte Broom, Tom Sapsford to name but a few. Hart does a wonderful job of Pinocchio and his mechanical movement and simple unfathoming mind, but my favourite has to be Will Kemp as Stromboli - a man literally bursting from his filthy clothes and with single minded evil determination that sees him bounce back with more skulduggery no matter how often he is thwarted. Broom and Sapsford as his assistants, the Fox and Cat, also ham it up well and move wonderfully.

A goodly Christmassy extravaganzitude for tiddly ponks of all agietypes I think.


* For foreign readers -this is cockney rhyming slang: porky pie = lie

Edit: fixed a typo or two... BM


  Printer-friendly page | Top
alison

17-12-05, 03:31 PM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail alison Click to send private message to alison Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
2. "RE: Review - 16 December 2005 Premiere"
In response to message #1
 
   Thanks for the review, Bruce, and so quickly, too!

In view of the shortage of seats, I think I may have to stand, and would appreciate any feedback from anyone about the relative merits of standing near the back or closer to the stage? I usually like the latter, but when I went to the Hans Andersen thing I definitely missed out from being too close to it.


  Printer-friendly page | Top
JohnM

17-12-05, 05:43 PM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail JohnM Click to send private message to JohnM Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
3. "RE: Review - 16 December 2005 Premiere"
In response to message #2
 
   I was standing right next to the stage last night and, though it was good to see the performers so close up, the (excellent) staging effects suffered. I'm sure it's better to be further back and more central.


  Printer-friendly page | Top
Mandy

18-12-05, 03:23 PM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail Mandy Click to send private message to Mandy Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
4. "Review - 17 December 2005 matinee"
In response to message #3
 
   ‘Pinocchio’ The Linbury Studio Theatre ROH
Sat matinee Dec 17th

Once again Will Tuckett takes us on a magical journey to another time, another world.
It’s a vaguely Victorian place with a strong Italian flavour, yet these are just part of the captivating whole.

From the start the audience are engaged by interacting with the singers as they enter the auditorium. Geppetto appears alongside Row A to introduce us to his story, brought about by his deep desire to have a son. Luke Heydon has been tempted back to the Linbury stage from his new career as a landscape gardener for this peach of a role. The little wooden puppet, played by the irresistible Matthew Hart, bursts forth from an ingeniously designed tree trunk at the touch of Geppetto’s axe, his limbs apparently able to hinge in both directions, his mischievous yet innocent nature conveyed eloquently through speech as well as movement. His guide, the beautiful Blue Fairy was danced by Cathy Marston, an ethereal vision in a blue frock with matching wig and scooter!

But it is Stromboli, the wicked puppeteer, who steals the show and has all the best lines and songs. Will Kemp, back in the by now obligatory moustache ( think Ratty and Soldiers Tale) bounces around with an evil leer, brandishing his whacking stick and thumping all who cross his path, so beware! His side kicks are the mangy Cat (Tom Sapsford) and the sexy Fox ( Charlotte Broom) who tempt and pursue Pinocchio away from his home and his father.

Of course good prevails and dreams come true in the end, but what a marvellous adventure is had on the way. The imaginative sets, designed by the Quay Brothers are kept simple but highly effective, for example a huge silken sheet patterned with waves and foam for the sea, and a giant ‘Chinese dragon’ style Whale which swallows up first Geppetto then Pinocchio.

It’s a real treat from start to finish, highly recommended to all. The promotional material stated suitable for over 8’s, but there was nothing very scary and plenty of 5-6 year olds who were thoroughly enjoying themselves and did not want to give their toys back to Stromboli!

I’ll be going again to see the second cast on Monday and taking my children to one of the workshops, so hope to report back on these later .

Mandy Kent


  Printer-friendly page | Top
Mandy

21-12-05, 04:03 PM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail Mandy Click to send private message to Mandy Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
5. "Leora Kent's Review - 17 December 2005 matinee"
In response to message #4
 
   Act 1
William Tucketts Pinocchio starts off with Geppetto (Luke Heydon) in the woods chopping trees when all of a sudden Pinocchio (Matthew Hart/Chris Akrill) comes out of a tree.
Now the thing that Geppetto wants more than anything is a son .So Geppetto takes him home and tries to find out his name, then a magical Blue Fairy (Cathy Marston/ Melissa Einkamerer) whispers in Pinocchio’s ear “Pinocchio” so Pinocchio says his name. Geppetto treats him like his own son and puts some clothes on him and sends him to school. On the journey he gets distracted by a puppet show which Stromboli (Will Kemp/Lee Bogges) runs so he swaps his slate for a ticket and gets up and dances!

The town people are amazed that there’s a puppet dancing with no strings. Stromboli wastes no time and pays Pinocchio cash so he will join his puppet show but Pinocchio says NO and leaves with Stromboli’s money. Fox (Charlotte Broom/Clemmie Sveaas) and Cat (Tom Sapsford/Alex Cowie) speak about the “Fields Of Miracles” and how it’s magical and if you bury coins there you’ll find a zillion riches. Stupidly Pinocchio falls for it and searches for the spot even though he should be going to school. But sneaky Fox and Cat dress up and follow Pinocchio and rob him. Pinocchio is sad as now he can’t find Geppetto until suddenly the magical Blue Fairy appears and sees Pinocchio is very sad

So she magic’s a special blue bird to take Pinocchio to Geppetto. As Pinocchio was looking for Geppetto, Geppetto was looking for Pinocchio. Geppetto thinks he’s in the ocean, so he takes a boat and sets out for sea but there’s a storm. Meanwhile Pinocchio arrives with the magic bird and finds Geppettos empty boat and thinks he’s as dead as a doornail!

Act two

Pinocchio is very sad. The magical fairy tells him real boys stand up when they think all is lost, real boys held their heads up high and are brave. Pinocchio starts to walk away but before he goes the fairy asks him some questions. The fairy asks him “Did you go to school?” “Did you go to a puppet show?” “Did you go off with a fox and a cat?” Pinocchio answered all in lies and somehow his nose got longer. “Now I will make your nose shorter if you promise not to tell lies and go to school?” “I promise”.
When Pinocchio got to school he had a teacher called Professor Winklebeam (Andy Morton/ Sani Muliaumaseali’i) who was teaching them brain boggling facts. But Pinocchio and his friends are twitchy. Lampwick, (Chris Akrill/Lee Boggess/Benny Maslov) tells them all about The Land Of Toys! They jump in to Stromboli’s cart and set of for the Land of Toys. The boys play with bouncy balls. But Stromboli says lets be real men and gives them alcohol and cigars and makes them play cards. Then Fox does a rude dance and suddenly the boys are turning into donkeys but worse than that it’s not the Land of Toys but the Glue Factory and Stromboli’s going to put the boys in the grinder. Then Pinocchio bursts Stromboli’s fat belly with a sharpened finger and he runs away. Pinocchio runs away to the beach and into the sea and he’s eaten by a shark. Inside the shark Pinocchio finds Geppetto. Geppetto asks “Do you want fish tail soup because I’m making fish tail soup?”
“Yes please” but before Geppetto could make the soup the shark sneezed and they fall into the ocean and are separated in the water. Finally they land on shore and Pinocchio sees Geppetto on the shore “dead” .Pinocchio cries in the corner when the Blue Fairy comes and makes Geppetto awaken and says to him “as you’re a kind man and always will be I am going to make your wish come true. Pinocchio has learnt many lessons and loves you like a real boy so I now present not a puppet but the real boy Pinocchio!” “Thank you, Blue Fairy for giving me a son!”

My comments about the show
I think the show was brilliant especially the end of Act 1 because I like the way the sea crashes on people!
I will see the cast with Mathew Hart soon to see if it’s different to the one I saw with Chris Akrill. My favourite characters would have to be Geppetto and the magical blue fairy. The show I saw with Chris Akrill was excellent so I gave it a 9/10. I didn’t give it 10/10 because Stromboli wasn’t talking clearly (I know he’s meant to be Italian but he’s a bit over the top)!
By Leora Kent



  Printer-friendly page | Top
JohnM

21-12-05, 05:25 PM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail JohnM Click to send private message to JohnM Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
6. "RE: Leora Kent's Review - 17 December 2005 matinee"
In response to message #5
 
   Leora, thanks for clearing up a few points in the story that I didn't get.

I too had trouble understanding Stromboli and I didn't at all like the way he beat people up. Did you think it was funny enough? I spoke to one very small person (too young to have been there really) and she seemed to have liked the fox's bushy tail, but that was about it!


  Printer-friendly page | Top
Mandy

21-12-05, 07:33 PM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail Mandy Click to send private message to Mandy Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
7. "Leora Kent's Review - 17 December 2005 matinee"
In response to message #6
 
   LAST EDITED ON 21-12-05 AT 07:34 PM (GMT)
 
I think some bits were funny especially when the balls went in to the audience. I think people older than the age 4 should see it.I mean its not very scary, well unless they think the shark and Stromboli are scary but I don't think its really scary and probably most people don't too. I thought that when they turned in to donkeys it was quite scary even for me and my mum!

I like the fox and her bushy tail too.I think Stromboli hitting
people was showing his horrible character just so you knew him better and hated him more.I think it was really funny when they wouldn't let him bow at the end.I liked the way glitter fell down in to the audience.I also liked the way Geppetto hits his bottom with his axe.I think it was excellent and hopefully everyone enjoyed it

Leora Kent


  Printer-friendly page | Top
Mandy

29-12-05, 05:56 PM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail Mandy Click to send private message to Mandy Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
8. "Thurs 29th performance and workshop"
In response to message #7
 
   This morning Elliot(13), Leora(9) and I attended a family workshop on the Pinocchio theme, held in the Crush Bar at the ROH.

We were 'coached' by staff from the ROH2 ballet and opera departments ...all on first name terms...so thank you Jane, Liz , Paul et al.....

We all took part in a vocal and physical warm up and then it was down to business being School Kids, Fox, Cat,Stromboli, Blue Fairy, Pinocchio and Geppetto. Our routine went so well I thought they could have used us as extra's on stage in the afternoon ( dream on!)Both adults and kids had great fun.

The performance this afternoon was very slick and I'm still laughing
at Pinocchio( Matthew Hart) and Stromboli( Will Kemp)and friends...though it's quite a dark piece at times and today some younger tots were disturbed by the Land of Toys scene which has very loud noises and where the children transform into donkeys. So the age 8 + advice should perhaps be adhered to ?

Anyway, we had a magical time!


  Printer-friendly page | Top
JMcN

30-12-05, 08:27 AM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail JMcN Click to send private message to JMcN Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
9. "Pinocchio"
In response to message #8
 
   I've booked to see Pinocchio at the Lowry and having read the reviews above I just can't wait to see it. I'm especially looking forward to seeing ex-NBTers Charlotte Broom and Chris Akrill again.

Janet McNulty


  Printer-friendly page | Top
Ann Welsh

30-12-05, 11:11 AM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail Ann%20Welsh Click to send private message to Ann%20Welsh Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
10. "RE: Pinocchio"
In response to message #9
 
   Daughter saw it last weekend and enjoyed it enormously.

Wasn't there talk about it being filmed for TV? If so, I hope put it on a terrestrial channel...


  Printer-friendly page | Top
Tony Newcombe

30-12-05, 11:22 AM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail Tony%20Newcombe Click to send private message to Tony%20Newcombe Click to add this user to your buddy list  
11. "RE: Pinocchio"
In response to message #10
 
   January 8th on BBC4


  Printer-friendly page | Top
AnnWilliams

30-12-05, 11:22 AM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail AnnWilliams Click to send private message to AnnWilliams Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
12. "RE: Pinocchio"
In response to message #10
 
   Ann, see this from a posting by Alison on the Christmas TV thread:

'>On 8 January, also on BBC4 at 7.20pm, from the Linbury, Will Tuckett’ all-singing, all-dancing Pinocchio will be broadcast; a must for all the family.<'

So there's still something to look forward to....


  Printer-friendly page | Top
Mandy

30-12-05, 11:24 AM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail Mandy Click to send private message to Mandy Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
13. "RE: Pinocchio"
In response to message #12
 
   Radio Times today states 7.15 pm start BBC4


  Printer-friendly page | Top
Ann Welsh

30-12-05, 02:31 PM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail Ann%20Welsh Click to send private message to Ann%20Welsh Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
14. "RE: Pinocchio"
In response to message #13
 
   Oh, Hut! My digibox doesn't have reception in my area, and I absolutely refuse to subscribe to Sky which provides only a fraction of the programmes I want to see. If anybody can record this for me, I'd be most grateful.


  Printer-friendly page | Top
Robert

03-01-06, 05:09 PM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail Robert Click to send private message to Robert Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
15. "RE: Pinocchio"
In response to message #14
 
   I am rather keen on the original Pinocchio story, so I was well prepared for this new musical production which I saw last week. The other Will Tucket Linbury productions have been very exciting and I was looking forward to Pinocchio. I am not sure it comes off as well as Wind in the Willows or the Soldiers Tale, and it is difficult to know why. It would be difficult for the music to be as good as Stravinsky’s in The Soldiers Tale but it is by the same composer that did so well with Wind in the Willows. Pinocchio is by no means as attractive as the residents of the riverbank so perhaps that is the problem. Both stories portray a world that is under threat, and both Toad and Pinocchio are sinners who land themselves in hot water and have to be rescued by their friends.
Pinocchio as a puppet is very much more difficult to portray than the pompous Toad. Stromboli the villain wonderfully overacted by Will Kemp is an excellent and likeable villain. Luke Haydon, on leave from his gardening business makes a sympathetic Geppetto, but I am not at all sure of Kathy Marstons’ Blue Fairy. Surely fairy tale fairies are beautiful magical beings, not middle class scooter riding mums. I remember ballet dancers appearing in Panto as fairies and doing a little bit of dancing to justify their inclusion in the show. All the fairies I saw were real fairies, the little people who come from another land to help the distressed hero or heroine in their hour of need. Kathy Marston cruised in on a scooter, an old device usually employed by the Dame. She did not speak , someone in the wings spoke her word over a mike and she did not move her lips. All illusions of fairyland were gone. I dread to think what it will look like close up on television.
The singing was very good and although amplified live. The male singer was a Samoan* with an impossible name(it even includes a comma!) He has a wonderful voice and proved to be an enthusiastic dancer, quite a useful man in this multitalented company. It is nice to see that Charlotte Broome is back in England and I hope her freelance career works out.
The sets and the effects have to be mentioned,. It is quite difficult to portray a storm at sea and a man overboard even more difficult to show the main character being swallowed by a whale, meeting Guseppo and being coughed up in a puff of smoke. The Quay brothers accomplished it with great taste and should be congratulated.
*Sani Muliamasealti'i(see what I mean!)


  Printer-friendly page | Top
JohnM

03-01-06, 08:45 PM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail JohnM Click to send private message to JohnM Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
16. "RE: Pinocchio"
In response to message #15
 
   I too had reservations about Pinocchio.

Half the fun of going to the theatre is the appreciative dissection which happens afterwards but sometimes this innocent pleasure can lead to a disgruntled desire for a wholesale rewrite. This was where I ended after Pinocchio, which prompted all sorts of ruminations about the nature of children's theatre, the importance of story-telling, the place of audience participation and so on.

Carlo Lorenzini's picaresque tale, published in 1881, is organised in 36 chapters, each presenting a self-contained episode from the life of the wooden rascal. Tuckett's writer, Phil Porter, has inevitably condensed and altered the original to fit it into an hour and a half but in doing so has blurred the story line. Porter opts to fudge the birth of Pinocchio who is plucked fully formed out of a tree, rather than coming to life under the carpenter's hands, which could have made a good coup de théâtre. He has also invented unnecessary and not altogether funny set pieces such as the scene where the baddy Stromboli corrupts all the children (played by adults) with booze, gambling and a rather unconvincing strip-tease. At the end of this the children, for no apparent reason, are changed into donkeys (in the book it's because they won't study and ignorant children are donkeys) which are then to be processed into glue. One assumes they are saved, but I wasn't quite sure.

Pinocchio at first seems an odd tale to modern eyes and ears. The puppet boy has all the appropriate characteristics of young males: laziness, mendacity and ignorance (though he is can also be loving and kind). The message seems to be that if you don't behave properly you can't be a proper boy, so all the undesirable features have to be knocked out of him by attempting to make him resist the tempters and villains that he encounters. There's a hectoring quality to this insistence on going to school, behaving well, having backbone and not telling lies. This slightly dubious moral philosophy is presented by Porter without irony (as in the original). On second thought it sits well with our government's overweening concern with antisocial behaviour in young people. The moral voice in Pinocchio is that of the Blue Fairy but could be that of Mr Blair. What would one not have given to have seen a Prime Minister lookalike dressed in blue tutu riding a scooter, rather than the conventional fairy as played by Cathy Marston. An opportunity missed.

But that would then make it a pantomime and this production is not billed as such. It is a 'family show', which I suppose means no bad language or sex - though of course there is no embargo on violence. It's child-friendly credentials are boosted by six post-show discussions and five family workshops but how many children will really find it comprehensible and fully enjoyable? We are not going to know, but it was very significant that the greatest animation in the audience was when beach balls were thrown from the stage into the auditorium and batted around for a while and, at the end, when glitter was rained down on the spectators. Other efforts at getting audience participation were half-hearted. The show starts with most of the cast being summoned out of the auditorium, but this idea is not followed up; later there was an attempt to get the audience to sing along or at least clap to the music. This is a show that cries out for panto type audience involvement ('LOOK BEHIND YOU...' and so on), but no. The best way to involve the audience is to get them to laugh but, although the script is clever and witty (where audible), much of the wit is adult, little is laugh-inducing.

Why do grown-ups think that children think that foreign accents are funny? Used for comic effect in the theatre they are alienating rather than endearing. Why has so much energy and ingenuity gone into inventing a lingua franca for Stromboli when it is scarcely comprehensible by adults, let alone children? (Comprehension is not improved by over-amplification - all the performers are miked even though no audience member in the Linbury is more than spitting distance from the stage.)

The staging has good effects, especially a silken stormy sea with model boat to show Geppetto's ill-fated journey and shipwreck when in search of Pinocchio. There are also scenes that redefine bathos, notably a Land Of Toys which consists of six beach balls, suggesting that the production budget had overrun. Something that cannot be faulted however is the application, skill and enthusiasm of the cast who make the most of sometimes thin material. I reserve my criticism for the progenitors.

I wish I could feel more enthusiasm for this piece from someone who has given much enjoyment in the past and surely will again.


  Printer-friendly page | Top
Robert

04-01-06, 02:03 PM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail Robert Click to send private message to Robert Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
17. "RE: Pinocchio"
In response to message #16
 
   Thank you JohnM for helping me understand my uneasiness about Pinocchio. Like you I have spent some time trying to analyse what was wrong with it and how it could be improved., at the same time I feel a bit mean about criticising it as I did not take my grandchildren and it is a Christmas show. I am not sure they would have enjoyed it although they would have loved your idea of a satirical Blaire Babe fairy!


  Printer-friendly page | Top
Sim

04-01-06, 04:42 PM (GMT (ST))
Click to EMail Sim Click to send private message to Sim Click to view user profileClick to add this user to your buddy list  
18. "RE: Pinocchio"
In response to message #17
 
   I must say I too agree with Robert and JohnM. I had high hopes after WITHW, but this did not live up to it, anywhere near. My daughter found it very boring; it just did not engage her, and a large part of the problem was those outlandish accents. My father was Italian, and neither he nor any of my other relatives or his friends who speak English sound(ed) like Gepetto, or Stromboli for that matter. As for the bizarre language Will Kemp has to speak as Stromboli, no-one could understand a word, which is fine if you know the plot and who/what he is, but a lot of the children and adults around us were mystified as to what he was on about. One of the parameters I always use when seeing a narrative or story piece is whether it would tell the story clearly if one didn't know it, and I think the answer in this case is that it wouldn't. I would have been completely baffled if I didn't already know what was going on. This is in no way to detract from the performances, all of which were excellent (I don't blame the accents or 'Strombolese' on the performers). I just feel they were a bit wasted here, especially Will Kemp who clearly has a real talent for comedy and zest for performing. I also wish there had been more for Cathy Marston to do; it is so rare to see her dancing these days that this little 'soupcon' was not enough!


  Printer-friendly page | Top

Conferences | Topics | Previous Topic | Next Topic

 
Questions or problems regarding this bulletin board should be directed to Bruce Marriott